In the early twenty-first century, learner engagement via digital learning was often measured through techniques that reduced engagement to simple metrics: the number of times a page had been opened, whether an online course had been “completed”, the number of unique users who interacted with a page. These techniques often relied on digital tools and platforms that were described as “academic surveillance technology” (Caines and Silverman 2021) and “Authoritarian EdTech” (Costello and Gow 2025). From the vantage point of 2026, this situation looked only to worsen in the face of “imperialist” AI companies (Hao 2025). A century on, this paper looks back on the interventions presented by strands of thought that were then referred to as Critical Digital Pedagogy, tracing how a new conception of online learning engagement emerged through fragile discursive shifts, happy accidents, and the uncertain but devoted labor of workers across education settings. While digital learning in the twenty-first century was characterised by creeping authoritarianism, the twenty-second has embraced autonomy. This shift, I argue, was enabled by experiments in critical fabulation and creative cross-pollination taking place near the end of 2026. Challenging the fantasy of digital learning as a panacea for the neoliberal university’s ills, these experiments produced new fantasies of possible pedagogic futures. Drawing on the work of diverse thinkers of the time including Saidiya Hartman (2019), Donna Haraway (2016), and M. E. O’Brien and Eman Abdelhadi (2022), I examine how speculative imaginings of autonomy in learning helped shape the landscape of digital learning to come.
Dr Sabine Sharp (they/them) is co-editor of The Routledge Handbook of Trans Literature (2024) and The Liverpool Handbook of Trans Science Fiction (forthcoming). They work as an eLearning Support Officer at The University of Manchester Library, creating digital resources on academic skills. Alongside this, they write on literature, TV and film, and engage in local activism on trans liberation, democracy, and biodiversity. Their interests include: slow pedagogy and digital minimalism; feminist, queer, and trans theory; and speculative fiction in all its forms.