AI preparedness is a wager on the future. Any claim about readiness embeds assumptions about what students will need and what education is expected to make possible. Generative AI makes one part of that wager visible in assessment because it can participate in producing the very work from which educational institutions infer learning. The larger stakes lie in what those judgments are supposed to prepare students for. In the United States, education has long carried a conversion promise: effort and credentials are expected to improve access to employment and mobility, even though those returns have never been reliable or evenly distributed. Using Gert Biesta’s distinction among qualification, socialization, and subjectification and David Labaree’s account of competing educational purposes, we examine which purposes govern readiness in relation to AI and what futures those purposes presume. We argue that the costs of institutional uncertainty are stratified. When educational assumptions fail, students with family resources or access to further training can absorb delay and redirection more readily than students with little margin for either. We use unequal futures to name this asymmetry: the same institutional miscalculation does not carry the same consequence for every student. We recast preparedness as judgment under uncertainty: recognizing when an expected pathway no longer holds and deciding what should follow. The paper asks what education owes students when it cannot know the future on their behalf, yet still organizes their preparation around particular versions of it.
Jameien Taylor, PhD, is Associate Teaching Professor of Sociology at Arizona State University. His scholarship examines how ethical life takes form through perception and relation, particularly amid vulnerability, pain, and environmental strain. He studies how people learn to recognize the presence and needs of others, how kindness and compassion become possible within those encounters, and how habits of attention bear on moral experience, cultural memory, and belonging.
Amber Acosta, PhD, is a Postdoctoral Scholar whose research and teaching examine how race, gender, class, and culture are lived through families, communities, and institutions. Her scholarship focuses on Black and Latina women and mothers, including motherwork, othermothering, kinship networks, and reproductive labor. Drawing on Black feminist thought, Chicana feminism, intersectionality, and reproductive justice, she studies how communities create practices of care and survival within unequal social conditions.