The critique of traditional grading systems is not a new topic, and is especially well-discussed in design education. While other disciplines can appeal to factual correctness, assessment in design rests, however lightly, on a bed of subjectivity; a design solution is not absolute – it is only an approach. To evaluate this approach against grading criteria dampens genuine interest and steers students towards low-stake outcomes because experimentation and trial-and-error carry a cost. Moreover, institutions that impose these systems are assumed to be the ‘guard rails’ that contains and maintains baseline conditions for all, providing an equitable point of departure; the same brief, the same instructor, the same timeframe and the same space. The unique factors outside the rails that may impact a student’s life are rarely accounted for. So what happens when these baseline conditions are destabilized, and even more so, disproportionately? It takes an extreme situation, such as the early 2026 US/Israel–Iran war involving the Gulf states, to lay these assumptions bare. As universities moved online and students were dispersed amid uncertainty, all rubrics, weightings, and grading criteria lost their footing. Topics that had once seemed compelling, and the role of design and education in itself had become drained of meaning. This presentation offers a personal account of teaching – and grading – under these conditions, and of what emergency renders visible about institutional structures that are long outdated and in dire need of reflection and reform.
Naz Naddaf is an Assistant Professor of Graphic Design at the American University of Sharjah, and holds an MA in Visual Communication and Iconic Research from the FHNW HGK Basel School of Design. As a multidisciplinary designer, her work spans branding, editorial, experience design and creative coding, alongside an active studio practice in the UAE. Her research examines identity in design, both as a subject – how the visual and material design of identity artifacts reinforces or interrogates structures of power – and as a question of pedagogy and the role a design educator holds.