Contemporary social and environmental problems are complex conditions that defy linear problem-solving, and design students are increasingly asked to embrace uncertainty, connecting disparate programs, forms, and sociopolitical narratives. A pedagogical problem occurs when students encounter this complexity but lack a systematic method for translating uncertainty into design action. Drawing from Albert Einstein’s idea of combinatory play and Arthur Koestler’s bisociation, this study suggests a methodical studio teaching strategy that allows students to find connections and derive architectural concepts from the collision of unrelated ideas and matter. The study examines two pedagogical experiments in an undergraduate design studio as a case study. Employing longitudinal visual artifact analysis, the research compares student work before and after these exercises, coded through comparative visual criteria derived from the repertory grid technique. The analysis charts formal transformation, spatial complexity, conceptual integration, and risk-taking. After the Domestic Parade workshop, where beginning design students were asked to physically transform nondomestic space into an inhabitable condition, the students’ work suggested a visible shift in formal transformation and spatial complexity. Following the 3D Collage exercise, which asked students to deconstruct machine parts and architectural precedents and reconstruct them based on eight questions that addressed imminent social issues, the students’ work began to indicate stronger conceptual integration and risk-taking. In conclusion, this study argues that combinatory play and bisociation can provide insights into the structured pedagogical approach of embracing uncertainty in design studio education and help students move from fragmented references to spatial propositions.
Sewon Roy Kim is an Assistant Professor of Architecture at Ball State University and director of Studio Serok. His interdisciplinary work spans art, architecture, and the humanities, with projects exhibited at venues including Guggenheim Bilbao, SAF, and Yale CCAM. Previously, he taught at the AA School and practiced at XPIRAL, Ábalos + Sentkiewicz, and Magicarch Architecture. He holds a Master of Architecture from Yale University, receiving distinction as the H.I. Feldman Nominee and Drawing Prize recipient.