Connectedness is widely regarded as a defining characteristic of integrated STEM education. Yet, while STEM integration research has focused extensively on curriculum design, pedagogy and interdisciplinary learning, comparatively little attention has been paid to how different forms of connectedness are constituted and represented. This study adopts a representation-oriented and phenomenographically informed perspective to investigate variation in representations of Natural Sciences and Technology integration among pre-service teachers. The study analysed Select-and-Fill-In concept maps completed by 40 Grade 6 pre-service teachers. Concept maps were treated as representational artefacts through which structures of relevance become visible. Guided by phenomenographic concepts of foregrounding, simultaneity, appresentation and structures of relevance, comparative analysis identified four dimensions of structural variation: foregrounding, organising principles, represented simultaneity and relational configuration. Organising principles emerged as the dominant source of variation, shaping how relationships acquired significance within the representations. The analysis produced a structural outcome space comprising four categories of description: Conceptual Organisation, Investigative Organisation, Material Transformation, and Relational Extension. These categories represent qualitatively different structures of relevance through which Natural Sciences and Technology integration became organised within the concept maps. The findings suggest that connectedness is not a self-evident indicator of integration. Rather, the educational significance of integration depends on the organising principles through which relationships among concepts, processes and contexts acquire meaning. Unpacking connectedness revealed that similar scientific and technological ideas could be organised through different structures of relevance and different possibilities for NST integration.
Professor Busisiwe Precious Alant is an Associate Professor at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Her research focuses on Technology Education, Indigenous Knowledge Systems, STEM education and sustainable development. She has supervised more than 25 postgraduate students, published scholarly works, and previously served as Editor-in-Chief of the African Journal of Research in Mathematics, Science and Technology Education. She currently serves on the Editorial Board of the Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics and Technology Education. Her current scholarship advances the Science, Technology and ICT Education for Sustainable Development(STIE4SD) framework, which reimagines Science, Technology and ICT Education in response to artificial intelligence, climate change, and digital transformation.
Rosann Naidoo is a Doctoral candidate in the Science and Technology cluster at the School of Education, University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. She is also Senior Lecturer at the Independent Institute of Education Emeris Westville campus in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Rosann has two decades of teaching and learning and research in science and technology education.