Artificial intelligence may be less disruptive for answering students’ questions than for prompting universities to face their own. For decades, educational researchers have emphasized that learning is social and experiential. Yet universities remain organized around transmitting, accumulating, and assessing information, even though this model sits uneasily with that view of learning. If information is no longer scarce, what is higher education’s purpose? Pedagogical experiments suggest an answer: a shift from information to formation. While machines can acquire and reproduce information, formation requires judgment, responsibility, identity, ethical awareness, social intelligence, and the capacity to act within uncertainty. Drawing on Dewey, Schön, and Lave and Wenger, the paper argues that educators must design the conditions through which tacit knowledge and professional judgment develop. Using student reflections, mentor feedback, and observations from two related experiments in architecture education—W_Internship, a ten-day immersive internship, and HI | AI, a professional practice course that uses artificial intelligence to shift attention from information toward judgment—the study examines forms of expertise that resist formalization and automation. In both settings, students report that their most valuable learning emerges through encounters with uncertainty, responsibility, office culture, client relationships, teamwork, and professional decision-making. Together, these findings suggest a framework for designing curricula that cultivate judgment, professional identity, and participation in professional communities. AI underscores what educational researchers have long observed: students do not learn mainly through information transfer. Yet universities continue to operate as if they do. The twentieth-century university focused on distributing information; the twenty-first-century university must prioritize cultivating judgment.
Margarita McGrath, AIA, LEED AP BD+C, is an architect, educator, and Associate Professor of Architecture at Virginia Tech. As co-founder of noroof architects and coordinator of the W_Internship Program, her work bridges professional practice and architectural education. Her teaching and research focus on experiential learning, professional formation, and the changing relationship between human and artificial intelligence in design education. McGrath’s work has been supported by the Arnold W. Brunner Grant and has been presented through publications, exhibitions, and invited lectures.