Artificial intelligence presents deep-rooted ethical issues about environmental and human cost and the nature of learning. These serious concerns now shape every decision about how and whether to bring AI into the pedagogical fold. Therein lies one of the many sources of tension educators sit in today. Cognitive research increasingly highlights the detrimental effects of AI on learning and the brain as there is a global movement for integration across K-12 classrooms, higher education, and many professional contexts. Teachers are expected to use AI, teach with it, and prepare students for futures where they are expected to be efficient users and consumers. This paper argues that all of this necessitates even more deliberate, values-driven pedagogy. As shown by exploratory qualitative research, dialogue, identity formation, and belonging are powerful human dimensions of learning. In one case study assignment, these experiences emerged most powerfully when students engaged in socially engaged pedagogy. Offered here is a set of reflective questions to provoke thought about their existing pedagogy, alongside a framework for reshaping instruction around the answers, informed by the AI Age context. As the world evolves rapidly, this framework serves as an educator’s commitment to returning, refining, and reapplying their pedagogy.
Rebecca Corso is an Assistant Professor of Education at Stonehill College, where she teaches foundational and methods courses in secondary education. Her research focuses on culturally responsive and anti-racist pedagogy, digital storytelling, and reflective practice in teacher preparation. She brings nearly a decade of secondary classroom experience to her scholarship, and that grounding in real classrooms shapes her approach to preparing the next generation of teachers. She holds an Ed.D. in Curriculum, Teaching, Learning and Leadership from Northeastern University.