Thomas Jefferson adopted Classical Architecture for the new American Republic as representing the best of Greek Democracy and the best of the Roman Republic. This was challenged in 1937 when Gropius came to Harvard. Gropius stated that when one designs, one starts from zero because we are in a new age with new programs requiring new interpretations. In the Classical tradition, precedent provides models that one may adopt, modify, use for inspiration. In the Modernist tradition process leads to a Big Idea that generates the building. In this Modernist method, one teaches architecture as a vehicle for the expression of an idea. The familiar studio fosters the student working alone with the critic to produce unique designs as individuated architectural expression. Using the Classical language, one approaches architecture as a Craft, with established strategies and forms, operating within a known tradition. With Zoom, all students are present; the studio instructor critiques and ALL students hear each critique and learn from it. Since students face similar problems, seeing the solutions of others is helpful and inspiring. The learning curve is nearly vertical. This paper will show that approaching Architecture as Art vs. Architecture as Craft leads to two very different pedagogical strategies and Zoom is helpful in teaching Architecture as Craft. Student work will be shown to illustrate the thesis. Works by Herdeg, Adamson, Sennett, and Bourdieu and others will lend support to the central thesis.
Laurence Keith Loftin III is a Full Professor at The University of Colorado Denver and a Registered Architect . He received a BA from Princeton, and later, a MA in Architecture from the University of Virginia. Late in his career, he recognized that most traditional architectures arise from the Classical tradition, which he has come to love. This tradition is a 4,000-year-old design conversation, with a focus on making Beautiful buildings. He is convinced that the study and design of Beautiful buildings will begin to redress many of the ills of our current dark age.