Traditional architectural studio assessment heavily favours formal deliverables and aesthetic outcomes, often marginalising the evaluation of process-driven, experiential, and embodied learning. This study offers preliminary empirical validation of the Phenomenology-Aligned Studio (PAS) framework by analysing external assessment data collected from a Semester-5, year 2 interior architecture cohort (N=55) at Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Puncak Alam, Malaysia. Expanding upon prior qualitative work on student self-reflections, this paper examines data from a multi-panel external jury (N=20 professional and academic jurors). Employing an integrated, hybrid qualitative methodology that balances descriptive phenomenological texturing with interpretive, hermeneutic data explication, we execute a mixed-methods correlation between hard programmatic criteria (site mapping, material prototyping, and space visualisation) and soft phenomenological metrics (cognitive awareness, affective insight, spatial/sensory sensitivity, and reflective practice). Concurrently, a qualitative thematic analysis is performed on the jurors’ written critiques. The quantitative findings demonstrate a strong correlation between high spatial/sensory sensitivity scores and superior physical material prototyping performance. However, qualitative insights expose a persistent critical gap: a “lost in translation” phenomenon where high affective and narrative empathy fails to materialise due to technical and graphic structural limitations. This paper contributes a robust, empirically validated assessment matrix that standardises external evaluation criteria, advancing an objective, process-oriented paradigm for human-centered design education. Ultimately, this integration of policy-aligned criteria with quantitative studio benchmarking proves that offers a potentially transferable, evidence-based methodology for reinforcing curriculum accountability across contemporary architectural programs.
Hafizuddin Haron teaches Interior Architecture at Universiti Teknologi MARA, Puncak Alam. His research and pedagogy emphasise phenomenology, embodied learning, and studio methods. He develops frameworks combining cultural analysis, material experimentation, and reflective practice to enrich interior-architecture education. Recent work investigates how lived experience and tactile engagement foster human-centred, empathetic design and heightened sensory awareness in students.
Zarina Za’bar is a Senior Lecturer at the Centre for Interior Architecture, Faculty of Built Environment, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Malaysia. She earned a PhD in Architecture from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia and brings over 19 years’ experience in interior architecture and spatial design. Her research focuses on architectural history, spatial identity, cultural heritage, and curriculum development. She has published and presented internationally and plays an active role in academic governance as a member of the curriculum committee for UiTM’s Interior Architecture programmes.