IN-PERSON Barcelona. Section A

Abstract

What makes the city of Edinburgh authentic? Is it its UNESCO world heritage designation, capital city status, or unique locality? This research seeks to unravel the complexities by investigating what matters to different groups and how they interpret and construct the city’s authenticity. Edinburgh emerges as a contested ground where the concept of authenticity is fiercely debated. The primary focus of this research is to explore the discursive battles over meanings, with a specific emphasis on the role of authenticity in the ongoing debates surrounding tourism and urban development in Edinburgh. Through an in-depth analysis of narratives and performances, the presentation illuminates the symbolic contest between two distinct groups: pro-tourism advocates, consisting of tourism industry leaders and marketers, and anti-tourism campaigners, comprising heritage enthusiasts, local activist groups, and ‘free’ tour guides. The methodology involves interviews, observations, and discourse analysis of news media, revealing the intricate interplay between heritage, tourism, and national identity in Edinburgh.